The comparable industry method values shares by comparing a company's dividends, earnings, and book net assets with data for listed companies in similar businesses. It does not mean using the same share price as a listed company in the same industry. The units of comparison are aligned, ratios between the company and comparable industry are calculated, and coefficients based on company size and other factors are applied.
Compare Three Factors on the Same Basis
The factors compared are dividends, earnings, and net asset value per share. Because companies have different share units, these figures are converted to a JPY 50 basis using stated capital and similar amounts. After calculation, an adjustment is needed to convert back to the company's actual shares.
| Comparison Factor | What to Examine | Points to note |
|---|---|---|
| dividend | Dividend history over the prescribed period | Also check the treatment of nonordinary dividends |
| Profit | Earnings adjusted under the circular | Do not simply use current net income from the income statement |
| net assets | Net assets at the prescribed book values | Distinct from the net asset value method, which revalues land and other assets |
The basic structure is to average the three ratios and multiply by the comparable industry's share price and a coefficient based on company size. Companies with high earnings alone, no dividends, or substantial assets will each have different combinations of figures. A decline in accounting earnings alone does not establish a particular percentage decline in share value.
A Simplified Example of the Calculation
For illustration, assume the dividend, earnings, and net asset ratios after conversion to a JPY 50 basis are all 1.0, the applicable comparable industry share price is JPY 500, the medium-sized company coefficient is 0.6, and stated capital and similar amounts per actual share are JPY 5,000. The average ratio is 1.0, so JPY 500 × 1.0 × 0.6 × (JPY 5,000 ÷ JPY 50) = JPY 30,000.
This illustrates the comparable industry value itself. The final valuation of a medium-sized company may combine it with a separately calculated net asset value. For example, if net asset value is JPY 70,000 and the blending ratio L is 0.75, JPY 30,000 × 0.75 + JPY 70,000 × 0.25 = JPY 40,000. Calculating the comparable industry value does not necessarily complete the valuation.
Industry Selection Affects the Result
The comparable industry is not determined solely by the company name or purposes in its articles of incorporation. Classification depends on actual transaction amounts by business activity. A company engaged in both manufacturing and wholesale, or offering multiple services, needs a revenue breakdown. Prepare a summary showing the basis for the classification.
Compare permitted alternatives under the circular, such as the applicable detailed classification and its broader classification. However, an unrelated industry cannot be selected merely because its share price is lower. Distinguish eligible comparisons from ineligible alternatives.
Align Published Data with the Company's Relevant Period
Check the relevant year when using comparable industry share prices and comparison factors published by the National Tax Agency. Share prices also have selection rules based on the month containing the valuation date and other factors, so do not automatically use the newest table at hand. Current-year data cannot be applied to a prior-year gift.
If data for the required month has not yet been published when planning a gift, distinguish estimates from final calculations. Clearly label the amount as an estimate based on currently published information, and finalize it once all required data is available, to prevent the estimate from being treated as definitive.
Spending to Reduce Share Value Also Reduces Company Cash
Hearing that earnings affect valuation may suggest that increasing expenditure is the answer. However, unnecessary business expenditure drains company funds. Whether it is tax-deductible is a separate issue. Reducing valuation at the expense of future investment or working capital may not benefit the successor.
For example, even if equipment must be purchased, its full cost may not immediately affect the earnings calculation. Capitalization and depreciation rules mean the reduction in cash and the change in valuation factors may differ. Model the company's cash flow and performance in subsequent years alongside share value.
When receiving a valuation statement, check the industry, data year, calculation basis for the three factors, and conversions to the JPY 50 basis and back to actual shares. Understanding what drives share value, rather than focusing solely on its size, makes the valuation more useful when considering succession timing.
Review the Earnings Adjustment Schedule
Show clearly which items were adjusted between income reported on the tax return and earnings used for valuation. In years involving substantial fixed asset sales or insurance proceeds, for example, check whether these can be treated in the same way as ordinary earnings. Record the starting line in the financial statements and the basis for each adjustment so that a new person can follow the calculation. When comparing with the prior year's share value, separating earnings adjustments from changes in industry data produces a clearer explanation than looking only at the final change.
References
- National Tax Agency: Basic Circular on Property Valuation, Paragraphs 180–184
- National Tax Agency: Standard Valuation Methods and Blending Ratios
Main References
Laws and systems as of August 7, 2026. Conclusions depend on the individual facts; please review the relevant documents when considering specific treatment.
Consider Your Family and Asset Circumstances
Move from general rules to your own case. See consultation topics and booking information.
Inheritance, Gift, and Business Succession Consultations →This article provides a general explanation based on legislation as of October 10, 2026. Always obtain individual advice before implementation.
We take care in preparing this information. If you notice an error, please let us know through our contact page.
