Transfer Pricing Rules Where consideration for a foreign related-party transaction differs from the arm's length price, the rulesdeem the transaction to have occurred at the arm's length price.What, then, is that price?The statute defines it not as a particular number but as “the amount calculated using the most appropriate method.”Method selection is built into the definition.
First, the deeming rule works in only one direction
Article 66-4(1) of the Special Measures Act.
... Where the corporation, from its foreign related party, receivesconsideration below the arm's length price,or pays that foreign related partyconsideration exceeding the arm's length price,then, for the corporation's income for that fiscal year,for purposes of the Corporation Tax Act and other laws concerning corporation tax,the foreign related-party transaction is deemed to have occurred at the arm's length price.
It applies only in the direction that understates Japanese income.Receipts are too low or payments too high. The opposite direction is not deemed adjusted. Moreover, this applies only“for purposes of laws concerning corporation tax.”That is the scope of the deeming rule.
Definition of arm's length price
Paragraph (2) of the same Article.
The term in the preceding paragraphat an arm's length pricemeans the amount calculated using, among the methods specified for the applicable transaction category in the following items, the most appropriate method, taking account ofthe nature of the foreign related-party transactionandthe functions performed by its parties and other circumstances,to determine the consideration that should be paid for that transactionif it were conducted between independent enterprises under ordinary transaction conditions.The method is selected to calculate that consideration.It is the amount calculated by the most appropriate method.。
Paragraph (2) gives no statutory priority ranking among the methods; this is the most appropriate method rule.However, the presumptive taxation rules discussed below contain an express priority order.
Three traditional methods for inventory: paragraph (2)(i)(a), (b), and (c)
| Abbreviation | Statutory name | Contents |
|---|---|---|
| CUP | Comparable uncontrolled price method(a) | The consideration paid by unrelated sellers and buyers for inventory of the same type,at a similar trading level, quantity, and under similar circumstances,is used as the price. Where differences exist butcan be adjusted, the adjusted consideration is included. |
| RP | Resale price method(b) | Resale price,receivesless the ordinary profit amount,calculated as resale price × the ordinary profit margin prescribed by Cabinet Order |
| CP | Cost plus method(c) | The seller'sacquisition cost,the return includesless the ordinary profit amount,plus an amount calculated as cost × the ordinary profit margin prescribed by Cabinet Order |
“Ordinary profit margin” is also defined by Cabinet Order.Article 39-12(6) of the Special Measures Order, for the resale price method, uses the comparable reseller'sratio of gross profit to total revenue,while paragraph (7), for the cost plus method, uses the seller'sratio of gross profit to total cost,in each case after adjustments for differences.The statute supplies the definition.The practical difficulty lies in selecting comparable transactions.
Subitem (d) is the catch-all
Paragraph (2)(i)(d)。
Methods analogous to those in (a) through (c), and other methods prescribed by Cabinet Order
The “other methods prescribed by Cabinet Order” are specified in Article 39-12,paragraph (8),items (i) through (vii).These provisions concern inventory transactions.For other transactions, the route is through “equivalent methods” under paragraph (2)(ii).
| Item | Statutory calculation structure | Common practical name |
|---|---|---|
| Number 1 | Income from acquisitions and sales by the corporation and its foreign related party:that incomeis allocated usingthe methods in (a) through (c) of the same item,namely (a) comparable transaction income allocation ratios, (b) allocation by contribution factors, and (c) basic profits plus allocation of residual profits and similar amounts,to determine the income attributable to each party.The resulting amounts are used. | Profit split methods: comparable, contribution, and residual profit split |
| No. 2 | Resale price,receivesandOperating profit margin on sales:the amount obtained by applying that margin, plus selling, general, and administrative expenses,Deduct | TNMM: buyer side |
| Number 3 | Acquisition costthe return includesandOperating profit as a proportion of total costs:the amount calculated using that ratio and related amounts,Add | TNMM: seller side, full-cost markup |
| Item (iv) | Resale price,receivesSelling, general, and administrative expenses,multiplied by the Berry ratio,and related amounts,Deduct | TNMM: Berry ratio, buyer side |
| Item (v) | Acquisition costthe return includesSelling, general, and administrative expenses,multiplied by the Berry ratio,and related amounts,Add | TNMM: Berry ratio, seller side |
| Item (vi) | At the time of sale or purchase,for the period during which profits or equivalent returns are expected to arise,the projected profit for each fiscal year is discounted usinga discount rate considered reasonable,to the time of sale or purchase,and the present values are totaled. | DCF method |
| Item (vii) | Methods analogous to those in the preceding items | ── |
Items (ii) through (v) cannot be treated as one method.They use different ratios—operating margin on sales, operating return on total costs, and the Berry ratio—and different directions of calculation: subtracting from resale priceDeductor adding to acquisition cost.Add)。
Pay attention to these differences.“Comparable uncontrolled price method,” “resale price method,” and “cost plus method” appear in Article 66-4(2) of the Special Measures Act asstatutory names.However,the terms “profit split method,” “transactional net margin method,” and “discounted cash flow method” do not appear in the text of Article 39-12 of the Special Measures Order.The Order describes the methods; those names are used in circulars and practice.
Presumptive taxation has a priority order
Article 66-4(12) of the Special Measures Act provides that, where documentation for a transaction subject to contemporaneous documentationis not presented or submitted by a specified date no later than 45 days,and in other specified cases, the district director of the tax office may presume an amount calculated by certain methods to be the arm's length price. This situation has a statutory priority order.
Article 39-12(20) of the Special Measures Order provides thatthe method in item (vi), the DCF-type method, and analogous methods under item (vii), may be used only where methods under items (i) through (v) and related methods cannot be used.This is the appointment procedure.There is no ranking for method selection under paragraph (2), but there is for presumptive taxation.Understand them separately.
Documentation and later price adjustments
- Paragraph (6) Documents considered necessary to calculate the arm's length pricemust be prepared or obtained by the return filing deadline and retained.Contemporaneous documentation obligation
- Paragraph (7) Exemption threshold: total consideration for transactions with a single foreign related party in the preceding fiscal year must beless than ¥5 billion,andintangible asset transactions must be less than ¥300 million.It must be in that form,
- paragraph (8), ── Specified foreign related-party intangible asset transactions,involving intangibles that aredifficult to value at the transaction date,where facts differ from the assumptions used to determine consideration, limited to forecasts made at the time,and those differing facts become known,allow the district director to use the amount calculated by the most appropriate method as the arm's length price,by deeming it so,when making a reassessment or determination.However, this does not apply where Cabinet Order treats the difference as not significant.
Paragraph (8) provides part of the answer to whether the selected method can later be changed.
Item (ii): equivalent methods
Paragraph (2)(ii).
Transactions other than those in the preceding item:methods equivalent to those in (a) through (d) of that itemare used.
All non-inventory transactions, including services, licensing intangibles, and loans, fall here.The statute does not provide independent methods; it refers to “equivalent methods.”
Points that require care in practice
- How is the most appropriate method selected?From the transaction's nature and the parties' functions. Paragraph (2) contains no priority order.
- What if no comparable transaction is found?Consider the Cabinet Order methods under (d).
- How is the ordinary profit margin determined?It is defined in Article 39-12(6) and (7) of the Special Measures Order. Selecting comparables is the difficult part.
- Which year's transactions determine the ¥5 billion and ¥300 million thresholds?The general rule usesthe preceding fiscal yearunder paragraph (7).
- How is consideration for services calculated?By applying the “equivalent methods” rule in item (ii).
- What if the price for an intangible later proves substantially different?Apply the price adjustment measure in paragraph (8) and its proviso.
Transfer pricing discussions concern methods, not just prices.The method depends on how functions and risks are shared with the foreign subsidiary. Companies transacting with foreign subsidiaries can consult us starting with an analysis of functions.
Legal basis
- Article 66-4(1), (2), (6), (7), (8), and (12) of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Taxation (Special Tax Treatment of Transactions with Foreign Related Parties)
- Article 39-12(6), (7), (8), each item, and (20) of the Order for Enforcement of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Taxation (Special Tax Treatment of Transactions with Foreign Related Parties)
This article does not cover the Special Measures Act Circular or transfer pricing administrative guidelines. Individual pricing requires analysis of functions and risks.
This article is a general explanation based on laws and regulations as of September 6, 2026. Please consult us about your individual circumstances before taking action.
We take care in preparing this information. If you notice an error, please let us know through our contact page.
If You Would Like Advice on Your Own Circumstances
We advise on international tax, including overseas relocation, foreign corporations, cross-border inheritance, and foreign tax credits.
International Tax ConsultationSee consultation topics, fees, and how to book.
